We want your news! Send us: News release |Letter to the Editor | Share a picture | Newborn | Birthday | Engagement | Wedding | Other Milestone
Today









Alan Jones Case Rests on Definition of “Depraved Indifference”

When Alan Jones was put on trial in 2009 for the murder of Erin Maxwell, Judge Walter Hafner warned then-District Attorney Donald Dodd that he was pursuing a risky theory of the crime.

Dodd charged Jones with a count of murder with depraved indifference.  It means, quoting the New York State Court of Appeals’ ruling in “People v. Feingold, 2006″, that murder with depraved indifference for human life “is best understood as an utter disregard for the value of human life—a willingness to act not because one intends harm, but because one simply doesn’t care whether grievous harm results or not”.

In a 2004 case, the justices wrote, “As the drafters of the Penal Law put it, depraved indifference murder is ‘extremely dangerous and fatal conduct performed without specific homicidal intent but with a depraved kind of wantonness’”.

Maxwell was strangled in her bedroom, police and prosecutors alleged.  Jones claimed he found her hanging in her bedroom.  He called 911.

The jury didn’t believe Jones and found him guilty of murder, but not before Hafner warned Dodd, with the jury out of the room, that Jones might be guilty of intentional murder but not of depraved indifference murder, under the rulings in place at the time.

The limits of the depraved indifference murder were tightened further earlier this year when the Court of Appeals ruled in People v. Bussey that a man who took part in the savage and fatal beating of another man was not guilty of depraved indifference murder.  The court said Bussey did not act like a man who didn’t care whether his victim lived or died.

The court reduced Bussey’s charge to manslaughter.

That case was the exact framework used by the Appellate Division in Jones’s case.

The justices wrote that the prosecution of Jones did not fit the two scenarios in which depraved indifference murder can be used in a one-on-one killing:

  • Where the suspect abandons a victim in circumstances in which the victim is likely to die, or;
  • Where a prolonged period of torture or beating results in death.

Jones “did not abandon the victim,” the justices ruled, saying that Jones “instead,…called 911 regarding the victim’s asphyxiation, administered CPR and was present at the scene when the authorities arrived.”  They ruled that there was no evidence of prolonged assault on Maxwell, saying that the evidence showed that her strangulation took no more than five minutes.

“Despite its ruling, the appellate court’s decision upholds and validates the jury’s finding that Alan Jones killed Erin Maxwell,” District Attorney Greg Oakes said at a news conference Friday. “Today’s decision does not cast any doubt on the fact that Alan Jones committed a wicked, horrendous and inexcusable act against a defenseless little girl.”

Oakes admits that “there were healthy discussions in the office” at the time over how to prosecute Jones.  Dodd made the final call, he said.  Dodd has since retired.

Oakes plans to appeal to the state Court of Appeals in time to delay the resentencing of Jones.  He also urged the state Legislature to refine the laws covering depraved indifference, noting that a 5 minute strangulation does not constitute depraved indifference to human life but an hour-long strangulation might.

Print This Post Print This Post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

 

Search Our Archives:

Fairgrieve students learning behavioral expectations

Students at Fairgrieve Elementary School in the Fulton City School District are expected to remain on their best behavior throughout the year as part of the school’s list of behavioral expectations. This week, as part of the school’s daily Morning Express assembly, students have been learning what their behavioral expectations are throughout different areas of the school.

Continue reading


Roker plans to broadcast live from SUNY Oswego on NBC’s ‘Today’

Al Roker, SUNY Oswego’s most visible alumnus, plans to bring his NBC “Today” show segments to campus Oct. 16. Long an ardent and generous supporter of his alma mater, the “Today” co-anchor and weather and feature anchor also plans to take part in the college’s 10th annual Lewis B. O’Donnell Media Summit at 2:30 p.m. Oct. 16 in the Marano Campus Center arena and convocation hall.

Continue reading


Court Gives DA Opportunity To Be Heard On Thibodeau Motion

Today (Sept. 18), the Hon. Daniel King, Acting Oswego County Court Judge, issued a scheduling letter permitting the Oswego County District Attorney’s Office to file a full and complete response to the CPL 440.30 motion filed by Gary Thibodeau on or before October 10, 2014. The court is permitting the People to respond to both the original motion filed by Thibodeau’s attorneys on July 30, 2014, as well as the Supplemental Affirmations filed on August 26, 2014.

Continue reading


‘Grape Expectations’ Wine Tasting Fundraiser Adds Themed Gift Baskets, Auction Items

Catholic Charities of Oswego County is hosting “Grape Expectations,” a wine tasting fundraiser on Sept. 28, from 3 to 6 p.m. at the River Vista Center, 810 S. First St., Fulton.

Continue reading


‘Magical moments’ of Cortázar to come alive in dramatic performance

Actor and director Milton Loayza of SUNY Oswego’s modern languages and literatures faculty will join forces with video/lighting designer Barry Steele to bring to life the stories of influential Argentine writer Julio Cortázar in a performance at 7:30 p.m. Sept. 30, in the Sheldon Hall ballroom. In “Don’t Blame Anyone” — the presentation shares the title of one of Cortázar’s short stories — Loayza and Steele will work together to show the audience Cortázar tales that Time Magazine says “can induce the kind of chilling unease that strikes like a sound in the night.”

Continue reading



v3_2014_64