Keeping Our Prisons Safe For All

By Senator Patty Ritchie
While the risk of violence is always present in correctional facilities, it seems that in recent times that violence has escalated.

Last year, inside New York State prisons, there were 798 reported assaults on corrections staff and 1,220 assaults on inmates by other inmates statewide.

In addition, officials confiscated more than 3,000 weapons and contraband items.

This winter, an inmate at the nearby Franklin Correctional Facility used a common, metal fork to stab a fellow inmate in the head.

We need to change this.

We need to protect our hardworking correctional officers, as well as others who work inside our prisons, and help them keep order.

It is hard to believe that after reading all of these stats, and about incidents like the one Franklin County, that metal eating utensils that can be easily used as weapons are still allowed inside some of our prisons.

The risk they present to correctional officers, other prison staff and inmates is tremendous.

As the daughter of a now retired correctional officer and a member of the Senate’s Committee on Crime, Crime Victims and Corrections, I feel this practice cannot continue.

That is why I have sponsored a bill, (S.8206), that would ban all metal eating utensils from prison cafeterias, mess halls and other dining areas of state prisons that house inmates serving time for violent and other serious crimes.

Under this bill, utensils made from either plastic or a composite material would replace those that are metal.

This bill also has support from former correctional officer and current Assemblyman Billy Jones who sponsors it in the Assembly.

Unfortunately, while the bill did pass a key committee recently, it was met with opposition from one single Democratic member of the committee who believed the bill ‘dehumanized’ inmates.

I would like to know what you think on this important issue.

Please visit my website and you can vote on my “Snap Poll” on whether or not you believe inmates should have access to metal eating utensils.

I am also proud to tell you there are more efforts underway to keep our brave correctional officers safe.

I have introduced legislation (S.2949A) to ensure adequate staffing in correctional facilities.

The bill requires the Commissioner of the Department of Corrections and Community Supervision to establish a staffing plan for all uniformed and non-uniform personnel, and to share a copy of the plan with the Legislature for oversight.

Another bill I sponsor (S.7525), would provide the families or beneficiaries of deceased correctional and community supervision officers with the retirement pension that would have been established had the member retired on the date of his or her death.

This would allow more experienced correctional and community supervision officers to stay on the job as newer, younger officers gain much-needed experience.

In addition, during the final weeks of this year’s legislative session, I will continue to focus on common-sense measures to ensure our correctional officers and others who work inside our state’s prisons are safe while on the job.

Hardworking New Yorkers want and deserve safer prisons.


  1. This sounds like a practical, common sense policy to me. Actually, I somewhat surprised it hasn’t been implimented long before now. They banned cigaretts in prison for various safety concerns, so why not metal forks and spoons? People use them at fast food resturants all the time, so what’s the problem? It would also seem to be more sanitary, and perhaps even more cost effective. I doubt that being in State prison “is a picnic” by any means, (with many essentially eating their own along the way), but since they are not going “out for lunch” anytime soon doesn’t mean that the politicians have to be. Sound like a good idea to me.

  2. The opposing viewpoint that this some how “dehumanize’s” inmates makes no sense at all (without any reasoning) as to how it actually does.
    As stated above, hundreds of thousands of places use plastic forks and spoons in their eating establishments. Does anyone really feel dehumanized by using them in such places? Is it a “dehumanizing” experience to drink coffee from a paper cup? In some parts of the world it would be considered a luxury. The only thing I could see that would be a “dehumanizing experience” would be the orange jumpsuits. However, I don’t have a problem with that, under the circumstances.

Comments are closed.